Tag Archives: Shaking

5 ways Tories are looking at shaking up UK football as Super League in tatters

Author [email protected] (Dan Bloom)
This post originally appeared on Mirror – Football

Plans for the Big Six English football clubs to join a European Super League lie in tatters after all six pulled out last night.

Bosses responded to a massive backlash from fans, politicians and footballers themselves over the “elite” breakaway plot.

It came hours after Boris Johnson threatened a “bomb” of new laws to stop the “cartel”, and last night he said it was “the right result”.

But ministers today say it’s “not the end” and they are now considering what reforms may be needed to the way the sport is run.

Sport Minister Tracey Crouch will still lead a fan-led review, which was promised in the 2019 Tory manifesto and set up this week.

Culture Secretary Oliver Dowden said it will look “at finance, it will look at governance and it will look at the fan experience of football”.

Chelsea fans stage a demonstration against the European Super league yesterday
Chelsea fans stage a demonstration against the European Super league yesterday

The withdrawal from the Super League means the biggest threats – windfall taxes, player travel restrictions and withdrawing police support for matches – almost certainly won’t happen.

But there are still some ideas the government is looking at. Here is what’s believed to be on the table.

German-style fan ownership

The review led by former Sports Minister Tracey Crouch will look at whether supporters could have a role in owning clubs.

One big focus is the ‘German model’ in which fans own at least 51% of shares and voting rights in their club. This is being examined “very closely” by ministers.

Mr Dowden said the fact German clubs were not part of the Super League “rather makes the case” for the German model.

“We need to look at options for fans to be able to have stakes in clubs,” he told broadcasters today, adding: “It’s very important that we don’t see this as the end of the process.”

He told LBC: “I do think it’s right that we look at how fans can have a stake in the game. I think if you go back a few years and certainly this is one of the things we discussed with fans, fans did have more of a stake a few years back, over time they’ve been bought out so I think that’s important that we look at that.”

A ‘golden share’ model

Ministers are also understood to be looking at a “golden share” model as a possible alternative to Germany’s scheme.

A golden share is a share of less than 50%, but which gives the holder powers of veto over major changes to a company.

So if supporters’ groups were to have a golden share in their club, they could block unsavoury changes in ownership for example.

A government insider told the Mirror measures will have to “show boards can be forced to listen to fans”.

Ofcom-style regulator

An Ofcom-style regulator for football is being considered, Culture Secretary Oliver Dowden said.

The Government has not ruled out the prospect of a new regulatory body, he confirmed, telling LBC: “The fan-led review will look at this.”

“Clearly we have got to get a balance. I want the Government to do as little as it has to do. The game is rightly self-governed, but I do think it is right that we look at governance questions like that, and that will not be off the table.”

Arsenal fans protest yesterday
The Government has not ruled out the prospect of a new regulatory body

Things to improve the ‘fan experience’

The review will also look at a “fan experience” around football.

This is likely to be more about the “daily frustrations” which fans face – for instance when going to away matches.

While the measures on the table are vague at the moment, it’s understood they could include laying on extra trains for example to get people home.

Competition law shake-up seems less likely

Mr Dowden had said he was looking at toughening up or enforcing competition law against the Super League.

But a government insider suggested that, while still possible, this was more a reaction to the European plans.

It seems less likely that it would be deployed to shake up football in and of itself.

… And no cap on players’ wages

Oliver Dowden rejected a salary cap, telling LBC: “I’m not putting that in the scope of the review. I think it’s right that it’s up to clubs to determine players’ wages.”

NFTs Are Shaking Up the Art World. Are They Also Fueling Climate Change?

“It’s really a big boom and the prices have been going crazy. But it can’t continue like this,” Mr. Lemercier said. “So there’s a sense that there is a very limited amount of time to make as much money as possible. So that’s why many dismiss this energy impact.”

The fallout has spread. Last month, the art app ArtStation, canceled a drop of NFTs from a group of popular artists just hours after announcing it, after a backlash formed over the environmental impact.

“It’s clear that now is not the right time,” ArtStation said. “It’s our hope that at some point in the future we’ll be able to find a solution that is equitable and ecologically sound.”

There has been pushback against the environmental concerns. In a recent post on Medium titled “No, CryptoArtists Aren’t Harming the Planet,” the NFT trading platform Super Rare addressed what it argued were misconceptions about the tokens’ emissions footprint. Blockchains like Ethereum were more like a train running all day, the authors said, and the transactions like seats on the train. NFTs, therefore, do not add emissions, they argued, just like a train would keep running regardless of how many passengers were on board.

However, Alex de Vries, a Dutch data scientist whose site, Digiconomist, tracks the sustainability of digital currencies, said that analogy did not hold up. “If one person doesn’t take a plane, it might not make a difference,” Mr. de Vries said, using a slightly different analogy. “But if a whole lot of people take planes, there’s more emissions from flying.”

Promises by some platforms to invest in carbon offsets have been met with skepticism, given the enormity of the carbon footprint from NFTs.

Saying, “Don’t worry! We’ll pay for carbon offsets” is the equivalent of setting a house on fire then placing a single potted plant on the burned property as “compensation,” the freelance illustrator Bleached Rainbows said on Twitter.

Hiroko Tabuchi
This article originally appeared on NYT > U.S. News